There are moments when being heard is not quite enough. Someone listened to our words. They may even be able to repeat them back to us. But somehow, what we meant did not arrive with them. Most of us know the frustration. “That’s not what I meant.” “You aren’t understanding me.” “That’s not why this matters.”
We try again. We add details. We search for different words. Because somewhere beneath the need to be heard is another deeply human hope: Please understand what I am trying to tell you.
Behind the Puddle
Sitting behind the puddle has taught me that understanding often begins with observation. When I first notice something, I do not necessarily know what it means. A bird behaves differently. The geese suddenly become louder. The heron chooses a different place to stand. The water looks different. A familiar visitor disappears for several days.
I can observe what happened. Understanding why it happened is something else entirely. Sometimes I learn more by continuing to watch. Sometimes experience gives me context. Sometimes I can research what I have observed. And sometimes I simply do not know. That distinction matters.
Because observation can become assumption remarkably quickly. I see something. I create an explanation. And if I am not careful, I begin treating my explanation as fact. We do this with people, too.
The Story We Create About Someone Else
Human beings are constantly interpreting one another. Someone does not return our call. We decide they are upset. Someone becomes quiet. We assume they are unhappy. Someone refuses help. We decide they are stubborn. Someone asks the same question repeatedly. We become frustrated. Someone cancels plans. We assume they don’t want to see us. Someone becomes angry. We focus on the anger without wondering what may be underneath it. Our interpretations may occasionally be correct. But they are still interpretations.
Understanding asks us to become curious about the space between what we observe and what we assume. Instead of: Why are you being difficult? Perhaps: What is making this difficult for you? Instead of: Why won’t you let me help? Perhaps: What does accepting help feel like to you? Instead of deciding we know, we ask.
Understanding Is More Than Agreement
We sometimes confuse understanding with agreement. They are not the same.
I can understand why something matters to you without wanting the same thing for myself. I can understand how your experiences led you to a particular belief without sharing that belief. I can understand why you made a decision and still wish you had chosen differently.
Understanding does not require us to surrender our own perspective. It asks us to become willing, for a moment, to look from somewhere other than our own. That can be difficult.
Our own perspective feels obvious because we have spent our entire lives living inside it. Another person’s perspective may not. Understanding asks: What does this look like from where you are standing?
To Be Understood in Advance Planning
This question becomes particularly important in advance directive conversations. It is relatively easy to document a preference. “I don’t want that.” “I would want treatment.” “I want to stay home.” “I don’t want my family taking care of me.” “I never want to live in a nursing home.” “I don’t want to be a burden.” Those statements matter.
But understanding asks us to go one step further. Tell me what that means to you.
Perhaps “I want to stay home” is really about familiarity. Or independence. Or pets. Or privacy. Or fear. Perhaps “I don’t want my family caring for me” comes from concern about physical caregiving. Perhaps it comes from witnessing another family struggle. Perhaps it means, “I don’t want my children to lose their lives while trying to preserve mine.” Perhaps “I don’t want to be a burden” is financial. Or emotional. Or practical. Or something much deeper about whether the person believes they will still matter if they become dependent.
The words give us the preference. The conversation helps us understand the value underneath it. And that understanding may become essential if the exact situation someone imagined never occurs.
When the Instructions Cannot Be Followed Exactly
Advance directives are written for futures we cannot completely predict. A person may describe what they want, but reality may eventually present circumstances no document anticipated. This is where understanding the person becomes as important as understanding the instructions.
If we know only what someone said, we may struggle when the situation is different. If we understand why they said it, we have a compass. We know what they were trying to protect. Independence. Comfort. Connection. Time. Awareness. Privacy. Family. Dignity. Faith. Home. The ability to communicate. Whatever mattered to them.
Understanding does not guarantee an easy decision. But it gives the people walking beside them something more meaningful than a checklist. It gives them context.
When Someone Cannot Explain Themselves
There may also come a time when someone cannot easily tell us what they mean. Illness. Fatigue. Disability. Dementia. Pain. Fear. Medication. Communication differences. Even overwhelming emotion can make language difficult.
This is when knowing the person matters. What have they told us before? What patterns do we recognize? What seems to bring comfort? What causes distress? What does their body language communicate? What have the people who know them well noticed?
We should be careful here. Knowing someone does not give us permission to decide that we always know what they mean. But history gives us context. And context can help us remain curious when words become harder to access.
The Relief of Not Having to Explain Everything
There is a particular comfort in relationships where we feel understood. Someone recognizes the story behind the sentence.
They know why a particular date is difficult. They understand why something that appears insignificant matters. They recognize the expression on our face. They remember the history. They know when we need conversation and when we need quiet. Not because they can read our minds. Not because they never misunderstand us. But because they have paid attention over time.
There is relief in not having to begin every explanation at the beginning. Perhaps that is part of intimacy. Someone has accumulated enough pieces of our story that today’s moment has context.
We Will Still Misunderstand One Another
Even people who love each other deeply will misunderstand one another. We will hear something incorrectly. Assume. React too quickly. Interpret something through our own history. Miss a cue. Ask the wrong question. Believe we understood when we did not.
Understanding is not a destination we permanently reach with another person. It is an ongoing practice. Perhaps one of the most important sentences in any relationship is: I think I misunderstood you. Can you help me understand? There is humility in that question. It acknowledges that our interpretation may not be the truth. And it gives the other person their story back.
Sometimes Understanding Has Limits
There will also be experiences we cannot fully understand. We may not know what it is like to live in someone else’s body. To experience their loss. To carry their history. To face their diagnosis. To live within their family. To make their decision. To hold their fear.
We can listen carefully and still reach the edge of our own understanding. Perhaps that is where honesty becomes important. We do not need to pretend. We can say: I don’t completely understand what this is like for you. But I want to understand what you want me to know.
Sometimes that may be enough. Not because understanding no longer matters. But because the effort matters, too.
A Practice of Curiosity
Behind the Puddle has taught me to leave more room between noticing something and deciding what it means. Watch a little longer. Listen. Become curious. Ask another question. Allow the answer to surprise me.
Perhaps we can offer people the same courtesy. When someone’s behavior does not make sense to us, perhaps there is context we do not have. When someone’s decision seems strange, perhaps there is a value underneath it we have not discovered. When someone’s reaction feels too large for the moment, perhaps the moment is carrying something older with it.
Understanding begins when certainty loosens enough for curiosity to enter. We will never understand another human being completely. Maybe that was never the requirement.
Perhaps the Human Need To Be Understood is not asking another person to know everything inside us. Perhaps it is asking them not to stop at the surface. Listen to what I am saying. Become curious about what I mean. Ask instead of assuming. Believe that there may be more to my story than what you can immediately see. And when you do not understand, stay curious enough to say: Help me understand.
Leave a Reply